HGTV is my go-to station while running on the treadmill, and my favorite show is probably Fixer Upper, starring America’s sweetheart couple, Chip and Joanna Gaines. I don’t know when that couple sleeps, especially Joanna: wife, mother, baker, designer, blogger. I hope they really are as nice as they appear on the show; I would hate for them to implode the way the Flip or Flop couple did.
Anyway. Joanna Gaines has great taste; I may not always like her design choices, but I can also see that other people do, and I can admire without wanting my house to look like her staged houses. But then there is the Chapman House:
The original house was a ranch style house with an atrocious second-story addition … not much you can do about it, but the exterior renovation on this part of the house looks good.
The porch, on the other hand … I am going to assume Joanna had a temporary blackout. Why would she think a gigantic unpainted rustic porch more appropriate to a Colorado mountain cabin would be a good thing to tack on a mid-century ranch? This is the sort of addition that on another HGTV show would be the first thing to be torn down. I can think of different porch designs that she (or rather, an architect) could have added to the front to balance the house. This is not it.
The Chapman House porch reminds me of another spectacularly bad renovation in my neighborhood:
This house is part of a post-war development where most of the houses were uninspiring Minimal Traditional style homes ranging from 800 – 1000 square feet. The neighborhood is a bit run-down with most of the houses being student rentals, but that is probably changing just because of the ridiculous housing boom in the city. The original house can still be seen, with new windows, new French doors, new stucco, and of course, the enormous ski jump masquerading as a porch. This house has been a work-in-progress for a year; I wish they had stopped a year ago. Or done something like this house, a block down the street, renovated with added square footage over the same time period:
The owners kept the integrity of the original house, and respected the over all spirit of the post-war neighborhood. Well done.